In February 1886, a small band of Chiricahua Apache warriors led by Geronimo eluded roughly 5,000 U. S. soldiers—about a quarter of the entire American army at the time—along with thousands of Mexican troops and civilian volunteers. The chase dragged on for months across the rugged Sierra Madre, a mountain wilderness so vast that even the most determined military commanders could not corner their quarry.
By September of that year, Geronimo finally surrendered with just 18 warriors, 13 women, and a handful of children. It was the last act of a conflict that had burned across the American Southwest for nearly 40 years. The question historians often ask is why the Apache Wars began. The harder question is why they lasted so long, touching off a cycle of violence, betrayal, and retaliation that outlived every general, every treaty, and every promise made by the U.
S. government. The Apache were never a single nation. Dozens of distinct bands—Chiricahua, Mescalero, Jicarilla, Lipan, Western Apache, and many others—spread across an area the size of a small country.
Each band had its own leaders, its own hunting grounds, and its own agreements with settlers, soldiers, and Mexican towns. There was no capital and no king. When the U. S.
government signed a treaty with one leader, it bound only his band. When soldiers punished one group for raids committed by another, the men they killed had brothers and sons who took up arms in response. That misunderstanding alone kept the fighting alive for decades. The land itself was another reason.
The Apache homeland stretched from the pine forests of Arizona’s Mogollon Rim down through the Chiricahua Mountains, across the open ranges of southern New Mexico, and into the Sierra Madre of northern Mexico. It was a country of cliffs, canyons, hidden springs, and summer heat that could reach 120 degrees. The Apache knew which cactus held water, which mountain sheltered a spring on its north side, and which pass could lure a rider into a kill zone. They could cover 80 miles a day on foot through brutal terrain and vanish.
Army cavalry columns, by contrast, needed grain, water, pack mules, and guides. They moved slowly and noisily, kicking up dust visible from 20 miles away. The Apache decided when fighting would begin. The conflict’s first spark came in the winter of 1861 at Apache Pass in Arizona Territory.
A settler named John Ward reported that raiders had stolen his cattle and taken a family member. The army sent a young lieutenant fresh from West Point, George Nicholas Bascom, to recover the captive and punish the raiders quickly. Bascom assumed the raiders were Chiricahua Apache and that their leader was a man named Cochise. He was wrong on both counts.
The raiders were most likely Coyotero Apache, unrelated to Cochise, and the captive was far to the north, beyond Cochise’s territory. Cochise, however, did not know that Bascom misunderstood the situation. Until that moment, he had worked to keep peace with the Americans, even holding a contract to protect Butterfield mail coaches passing through Apache Pass. He came to the meeting as a man expecting negotiation, bringing his brother, two nephews, his wife, and his son.
Bascom declared him a prisoner. Cochise cut through the canvas tent behind him and escaped into the rocks, but his family was captured. For the next twelve days, both sides tried to negotiate. Cochise took hostages from a nearby wagon train and offered an exchange.
Bascom refused, demanding the boy from Ward’s ranch. Cochise did not have the boy and could not produce him. As they left Apache Pass, Bascom executed Cochise’s brother and two nephews, along with three other Apache men, leaving the bodies for Cochise to find. Some historians estimate that the killings in that single week cost the lives of thousands of Americans over the following decade.
The number may be exaggerated, but it points to a real consequence: a young officer who misread a situation, refused to admit he was wrong, and turned a peaceable leader into an enemy who spent the next eleven years hunting anyone in a blue uniform. Cochise later told the territorial governor plainly: “I was at peace with the Americans. I did not want war, but your soldiers came and killed my brothers and hanged them on a tree and left them there, so I went to war. ”
Two years later, in the winter of 1863, the same pattern repeated itself with the most powerful Apache leader alive, Mangas Coloradas.
Around seventy years old and nearly six feet tall, Mangas Coloradas had fought the Mexicans for three decades and the Americans for a decade. He had been wounded the previous summer at Apache Pass and barely survived. In January 1863, he decided to try once more for peace. A small group of California militia and miners raised a white flag near Pinos Altos in southwestern New Mexico, saying they wanted to talk.
Mangas Coloradas came with twelve companions, expecting a genuine negotiation and trusting what a white flag meant anywhere in the civilized world. Instead, armed soldiers emerged from hiding and seized him. They marched him fifteen miles south to Fort McLane, an adobe post reopened for a campaign by General Joseph Rodman West. That night, West issued an order to the guards.
One miner present wrote it down, and multiple accounts confirm the wording: “Men, that old murderer has eluded every military command and left a trail of blood 500 miles on the old line. I want him dead tomorrow morning. Do you understand? I want him dead.
”
The guards understood perfectly. That night, January 18, 1863, they heated their bayonets in the fire until the metal glowed, then pressed the hot iron against Mangas Coloradas’s body as he lay bound on the ground. When he flinched and tried to rise, they shot him, claiming he was attempting to escape. The official report the next morning stated that the prisoner had been killed while trying to flee.
The record did not end there. The post surgeon wanted the man’s skull for scientific purposes. He boiled the head to remove the flesh and eventually sent the skull east to a phrenologist in New York named Orson Fowler, who wrote admiringly about it in his 1873 book. The skull was later put on display.
When Fowler’s collection dispersed, the skull vanished and was never found. The message was unmistakable. When your enemy sends his most respected leader under a white flag of truce and you torture, kill, and decapitate him, you do not just kill one man. You destroy the possibility of future peace negotiations for an entire generation.
Every son, grandson, and warrior who heard the story—and they all heard it—would remember it the next time a soldier spoke the word “peace. ”
Cochise heard about it and did not come to negotiate for the next nine years. He lived in the Dragoon Mountains of southeastern Arizona, in a natural fortress of granite peaks that became known as Cochise Stronghold. From that base, he raided farms, wagon trains, stagecoaches, and army columns—not every day, but often enough.
Each time, he faded back into the rocks, into country the army could not follow. The army never forced him into a pitched battle. Not once in nine years. Another factor sustained the war: the international border.
When a raid occurred north of the border, the Apache could ride south into Mexico and out of reach of the U. S. Army. When a raid occurred south of the border, they could ride north and out of reach of the Mexican Army.
Two countries, two flags, one people who recognized neither. The two governments did not sign an agreement allowing hot pursuit across the border until 1882, and even then, the mountains were so vast that a small group of Apache who knew every trail could evade an entire army indefinitely. In 1885, when General George Crook chased Geronimo into the Sierra Madre, his scouts searched every pass and watercourse for months. They found abandoned fires and footprints, but never the main camps.
There was an even crueler reason the war continued, one that the army did not want to acknowledge publicly because it did not fit a nation that saw itself as fighting for civilization. The Apache Wars were also a story of corruption. By the early 1870s, a group of businessmen in Tucson had discovered a way to make a great deal of money from the war—not by winning it, but by keeping it going. Historians call this informal alliance the Tucson Ring.
Every time the army built a new fort in Apache country, that fort needed hay for horses, beef for soldiers, grain, lumber, tools, wagon parts, and boots. All of it had to be purchased locally through government contracts, and the Tucson Ring controlled many of those contracts. Some were priced at three or four times the cost of the same goods in the East. Every time the army built a reservation, that reservation needed rations: flour, beef, blankets, and coffee.
The Indian agent appointed by the government was often connected to the same business group. Flour was cut with other substances to add weight. Beef was often the thinnest cattle in the herd, weighed alive, so the seller was paid for the water in the animals’ stomachs. Blankets were thin, and part of what was meant for the Apache was secretly diverted and sold on the open market.
A reservation resident who was told to give up guns and horses, stop raiding, and trust the government to feed his family might show up on ration day to find the food insufficient to keep a family alive through winter. The choice was hunger, begging, or riding out to hunt or raid to feed one’s people. Every time a band left the reservation for that reason, outraged Tucson newspapers demanded an army response, which meant more troops, more forts, and more contracts. General George Crook, who fought the Apache twice, once from 1871 to 1875 and again from 1882 to 1886, wrote about the Tucson Ring in terms that still surprise people.
He essentially said that certain civil interests in the region were deliberately provoking conflict and that some Apache escapes he was sent to punish were caused by reservation conditions no human being could endure. Crook was not a soft man. He spent his entire adult life in uniform, hunting men. But he spent enough time listening to Apache scouts and prisoners to understand something most of his fellow officers did not: much of the fighting was not because the Apache were violent, but because they were hungry.
In the summer of 1871, an event occurred that stained the entire war permanently. It is called the Camp Grant Massacre. Camp Grant was a military post near the junction of Aravaipa Creek and the San Pedro River in southern Arizona. A group of Aravaipa Apache led by a chief named Eskiminzin had come in and asked for peace, and they were allowed to camp near the post.
They were farming. They were gathering mescal. By all accounts, they were doing exactly what the U. S.
government had asked them to do. On the night of April 29, 1871, a mob of Anglo-American and Mexican settlers from Tucson, along with a large party of allied Tohono O’odham warriors, marched 60 miles north. At dawn, they attacked the sleeping camp. Most of Eskiminzin’s men were absent, hunting in the mountains.
The army officers who arrived that morning found things that stayed with them for the rest of their lives. Eskiminzin returned to the camp to find nearly every relative he had dead. President Ulysses S. Grant himself called it outright murder and threatened to impose martial law over all of Arizona Territory if the perpetrators were not prosecuted.
They were tried in Tucson before a jury of local citizens. It took 19 minutes to acquit every one of them. The Camp Grant Massacre changed the course of the war. Eskiminzin had come voluntarily, done what the Americans asked, and trusted them.
When that trust proved worthless, every other Apache leader on the border saw it. For years afterward, whenever an American officer appeared at a camp with an offer of peace, the Apache would quietly ask whether the officer would protect them the way Camp Grant had been protected. Around 1872, the government tried a different approach. A one-armed Union general named Oliver Otis Howard, known as the Christian General because he took his faith seriously, was sent to negotiate directly with Cochise.
Howard went almost alone, accompanied by just two men, into the heart of the Dragoon Mountains and sat down with the man the whole territory feared. Their intermediary was a red-bearded frontiersman named Thomas Jeffords, a former mail station superintendent who had entered Cochise’s stronghold years earlier, alone and unarmed, to ask the chief to stop killing stagecoach drivers. Cochise was so impressed by his audacity that he made him a lifelong friend. Now Jeffords brought Howard to meet him.
The talks lasted 11 days. In the end, Cochise agreed to peace on the condition that Jeffords be made the Indian agent for a new Chiricahua reservation, and that the reservation be located in the land where the Chiricahua actually lived, not somewhere the government wanted to put them. Howard agreed. Peace held for two years, until Cochise’s death in June 1874.
During that time, according to the records, the Chiricahua Apache carried out no raids inside the United States. Not once. That was the moment the war should have ended. If the U.
S. government had honored that peace and left the Chiricahua in their homeland with a reasonable agent and reasonable rations, the Apache Wars might well have concluded by 1875. Two years after Cochise’s death, in 1876, the government abolished the Chiricahua reservation. Agents pulled Jeffords out, gathered the Chiricahua, and forced most of them onto the San Carlos reservation north of the Gila River, in land that was not theirs.
The Apache called the place something that was never really improved upon: forty acres of hell. San Carlos sat on a low-elevation river bottom. In summer, temperatures reached 120 degrees. Mosquitoes carried malaria.
The water was bad. Different Apache bands that had been enemies for generations were forced to share one camp. Rations were often meager. Agents were often corrupt.
The mountains that had always been home, the pine forests where they hunted, and the springs where their ancestors drank were now forbidden. Had someone deliberately designed a place guaranteed to produce warriors who would flee and ride south to raid, they could not have done better. Between 1876 and 1886, there were at least five major escapes from San Carlos, each one a story in itself. The most famous early escape, which became a war within the war, was led by a Chiricahua Apache war leader named Victorio.
By the time matters came to a head, Victorio was a war leader in his fifties. He had ridden with Mangas Coloradas as a young man. He had signed treaties. He had tried farming.
He had done what was asked of him. What he wanted was simple: he wanted his people, the Warm Springs Chiricahua, to be allowed to live on their own land in southwestern New Mexico. That was the entire demand. The government moved them to San Carlos anyway.
In September 1877, Victorio left the reservation. He was brought back. He left again. In 1879, he left for good with about 60 warriors and their families.
Over the next fourteen months, he led a campaign that some military historians consider one of the most skillful guerrilla operations in the history of North America. He fought the U. S. Cavalry, the Mexican federal troops, and the Texas Rangers.
He crossed the border again and again. He attacked farms and then vanished. He fought pitched battles in the Black Range, the San Andreas Mountains, and the Guadalupe Mountains, and he never lost his ability to move. He was in his late fifties or sixties, sometimes ill, yet he exhausted the armies of two nations.
The end came in October 1880, when Victorio was in Mexico in the Tres Castillos hills of northern Chihuahua. He was cornered by a Mexican force under Colonel Joaquin Terrazas, along with a large number of Tarahumara scouts and militia, in a group of low hills that were nearly waterless. There were about 78 fighters with Victorio at that moment. They faced more than 300 Mexican soldiers.
The battle lasted two days, and on October 15, 1880, Victorio was killed. Accounts conflict. Some Apache traditions say he took his own life rather than be captured. Some Mexican reports credit the fatal shot to a Tarahumara scout named Mauricio Corredor.
What is undisputed is that he died—but even that did not end the fighting. An elderly Apache man named Nana, who had ridden with Mangas Coloradas in the 1840s, escaped from Tres Castillos with about 17 survivors. Nana was in his seventies and reportedly suffered from arthritis so severe that he could barely mount a horse without help. In the summer of 1881, this old man set out from the Sierra Madre with a small force of no more than 40 warriors on what became known as Nana’s Raid.
Over six weeks, he covered somewhere between 1,000 and 3,000 miles across New Mexico. He fought eight separate engagements against the U. S. Cavalry and won or fought to a draw in every one.
He captured horses, replenished supplies, and crossed back into Mexico. No American force could catch him. He was in his seventies, riding with a rifle, outmaneuvering the U. S.
Army. Geronimo’s name is the one everyone knows, but the story most people carry is not entirely accurate. Geronimo was never a tribal chief. He was a war leader and medicine man of the Bedonkohe band of the Chiricahua Apache.
He was born around 1829 near the headwaters of the Gila River in what is now New Mexico, with the name Goyahkla, usually translated as “one who yawns. ” He grew up in a country where his people had been at war with Mexico for a generation. He married young and had a wife and family. In 1858, Mexican cavalry under Colonel Jose Maria Carrasco attacked a Chiricahua camp near the Mexican town of Janos in Chihuahua.
Most of the men were away. When Goyahkla and the other warriors returned that night, they found the camp destroyed. Goyahkla lost his wife, his mother, and his three children. Nearly everyone he loved was gone.
Some accounts say he had a vision; he later said he heard a voice telling him that no bullet would ever kill him. Whether one believes that or not, this was where the story of the fighter later known as Geronimo began—not in a fight against Americans, but on a night ride through the ruins of a family camp in Mexico. Over the next thirty years, he made sporadic raids south of the border in revenge for that night, sometimes with a large force, sometimes with just a few men. He was not always at war.
He entered reservations more than once. He tried farming at Turkey Creek, then left. He came back, then left again. By 1885, he was one of the last free Apache in Mexico, and the entire U.
S. Army was chasing him. In 1886, Geronimo’s band consisted of just 18 to 36 warriors, plus women and a few non-combatants. Against them, the U.
S. government deployed about 5,000 soldiers—roughly a quarter of the entire American army at the time—plus a nearly equal number of Mexican troops and hundreds of civilian volunteers. Two nations, and yet Goyahkla eluded them month after month for most of the year. General George Crook negotiated one surrender with him in March 1886 in a canyon in Sonora called Canyon de los Embudos.
During that meeting, photographer Camillus Fly took the only known photographs of an Apache leader in the field in war paint before surrender. But that night, a smuggler named Bob Tribolet entered the camp with whiskey and told Geronimo that if he returned to U. S. territory, he would be hanged.
Whether or not Geronimo believed him, he and a small group slipped away in the dark. Crook was relieved of command over that loss. His replacement was Nelson Miles. Miles kept his 5,000 men busy.
He built a chain of heliograph stations, using mirrors to flash sunlight across mountain peaks, signaling movements faster than had ever been possible before. He rotated exhausted horses with fresh ones constantly. He watched every water hole in a wilderness the size of Kentucky. And he sent a young lieutenant named Charles Gatewood, with two Apache scouts, deep into the Sierra Madre to find Geronimo one last time.
Gatewood found him in the last week of August 1886. He walked into Geronimo’s camp with just two men. Geronimo could have killed him, and everyone there knew it. Gatewood sat by the fire and told him the truth.
He told Geronimo that every remaining Chiricahua at the reservation, including those who had never fought, had been arrested and put on trains heading for prison in Florida. Their women, their elders, everyone—even the scouts who had served the army faithfully—would be sent away. There was no reservation left to return to. Geronimo asked what would happen if he refused to surrender.
Gatewood said, according to his own account, that he did not know for certain, but Miles had 5,000 men in the field, and one of them would eventually find the camp, and when that happened, Geronimo’s warriors would die and so would their families. They talked through the night. At dawn, Geronimo agreed to head north and speak to Miles personally. The surrender took place at Skeleton Canyon in the far southeastern corner of Arizona Territory on September 4, 1886.
There were 18 warriors with Geronimo, 13 women, and a few others. That was all that remained of the Chiricahua resistance. That was what a quarter of the U. S.
Army had been chasing. Miles promised, or at least implied, that Geronimo and his people would eventually be allowed to return to Arizona. He was lying, though historians still debate whether he knew it at the time. Geronimo was put on a train and shipped to Florida as a prisoner of war.
So were the Chiricahua scouts who had helped the army find him. Every one of them. Geronimo never saw Arizona again. He lived out the rest of his life at Fort Sill in Oklahoma Territory.
He rode in Theodore Roosevelt’s inaugural parade in 1905. He appeared at the St. Louis World’s Fair. He died of pneumonia in 1909, still officially a prisoner of war, on a February morning after, according to one account, falling drunkenly from his horse into a creek.
The last Chiricahua prisoners of war were not released until 1913, 27 years after Geronimo’s surrender. Some of them had been born in captivity by then. That is how the Apache Wars ended. The answer to why they lasted so long was not one cause but a stack of them, each making the next worse.
The land was a fortress the Apache understood and the army did not. The Apache were not one people, and the Americans kept trying to make peace as if they were. Early betrayals, like the Bascom affair and the murder of Mangas Coloradas under a flag of truce, poisoned the ground so thoroughly that no later officer, not Howard, not Crook, not Gatewood, could fully repair it. The border with Mexico gave the Apache a refuge neither government could enter without permission, and permission was slow in coming.
Certain civic interests in the territory profited from the war and worked quietly and effectively to keep it alive. The reservation system, especially at San Carlos, was designed in a way that guaranteed escapes because it made survival on the reservation nearly impossible. And every time one Apache leader was killed, another emerged. Mangas Coloradas died, and Cochise fought harder.
Cochise died, and Victorio rose. Victorio died, and Nana rode out. Nana slowed down, and Geronimo carried on. Each generation of the war produced a new man who could not or would not stop.
Neither side was purely heroic or purely villainous. The Apache raided farms, killed settlers, and took captives. They were human beings doing human things in a world where doing so was the difference between their families eating or starving. The soldiers, mostly low-paid recruits, were in a country they had never seen, doing what they were ordered to do, dying of thirst and heat and Apache bullets in canyons whose names appear in no book.
Officers like Crook and Howard and Gatewood sometimes tried to do the right thing as they understood it, and were relieved or ignored for it. Officers like Bascom and West did the wrong thing and set the whole world aflame. The people who profited in the long run were mostly those who never saw a fight: the Tucson businessmen, the miners who wanted Apache land opened up, the politicians in Washington. They made their money or built their careers on other people’s corpses.
The land itself remains. Travel to Fort Bowie and Apache Pass today, and one can still find the ruins of stone breastworks that warriors used on that hill in July 1862 to fire down on a California column. The rocks are still stacked as they left them. The spring is still there.
The wind still smells of creosote after rain. The Apache today live on the Mescalero reservation in New Mexico, some at Fort Sill, and others scattered across the country. But the land that made them is still there, and it does not forget. In a sense, no one won.
The Apache bands were broken up and shipped east. The soldiers who defeated them were sent to other wars in Cuba and the Philippines, and then forgotten. The Tucson Ring made its money and moved on. The next generation of Americans put up a monument at Skeleton Canyon and called it history.
But the land is still there. You can almost hear a war that took 40 years to finish but never truly ended, not in the way we like to pretend our wars end.