The Tragedy That Rewrote Britain’s Throne: Princess Charlotte

The Tragedy That Rewrote Britain's Throne: Princess Charlotte

On a November night in 1817, a notice went up from a quiet house in Surrey. The princess, it said, was doing extremely well. She had a few hours left to live.

Her name was Charlotte, the only child of the Prince Regent, the future King George IV. She was the heir the whole nation was waiting for, the queen everyone wanted. She would die before she could wear the crown, and her death would quietly hand the throne to a girl not yet born named Victoria.

In the autumn of 1817, the shops of England ran out of black cloth. The linen drapers could not keep pace. In towns where no one had ever seen her face, working men tied dark rags around their sleeves, and the gambling houses closed their doors, and the Royal Exchange fell silent.

One man wrote that it was as though every household in the country had lost a favorite child of its own. They were mourning a young woman of 21. Her name was Princess Charlotte of Wales, and for the whole of her short life, she had been the most watched person in Britain.

The only child of the Prince Regent, she stood next in line after her father. She was the heir the nation was waiting for. She was also, almost from birth, a kind of stranger in her own family.

Her mother and father had loathed one another before she was born and parted soon after. Her father kept her at arm's length in a separate house cared for by people who were paid to be there. He gave her gifts in place of his time.

When she came of age, he tried to trade her marriage away like a clause in a treaty. What he did not expect was that his daughter would refuse. That she would break the engagement herself. That she would one summer afternoon run out of her own front door and into a London street and disappear in a common hired cab fleeing her own father.

Charlotte was born into a quarrel. Her mother and father had disliked one another on sight. George, Prince of Wales, had married his cousin Caroline of Brunswick chiefly to persuade Parliament to clear his enormous debts. Within months, the two had separated.

The infant who arrived in January of 1796 was the one thread still binding them together, and neither of them, in truth, seemed to want the thread. She was the living proof of a marriage they both wished had never happened.

When she was eight, her father decided that he wanted Carlton House, his grand London palace, to himself. He moved his daughter next door into a separate establishment called Warwick House, her own small court, her own servants, her own quiet rooms.

There was a governess she loved, Lady Elgin, the woman who had cared for her since she was tiny. She was taken away. The real reason, most historians believe, was that she had committed a small crime. She had let Charlotte visit the king without her father's permission.

And so the child learned, early and permanently, that the people she grew attached to could be removed without warning by a hand she could not see and could not argue with.

Charlotte did not grow up meek. She grew up loud. She rode hard and fast and often. She had a temper no governess ever fully tamed and a habit of speaking her mind that alarmed the careful people paid to shape her.

By every honest account, she was clever and quick, a dreadful speller, and far more interested in politics and horses than in the graces expected of a future queen. When she was 16, she read a new novel by an anonymous lady, a book called Sense and Sensibility, and wrote to a friend that she had finished it, that it interested her very much, and that she rather thought she resembled Marianne in it.

The same imprudence, she admitted cheerfully, if not, she confessed, quite the same goodness. The spelling in the letter wanders all over the page. The voice is completely, defiantly, alive.

Here was a real girl, headstrong, funny, warm, hungry for affection, and almost no one in her life had any use for her as a person. To the diplomats, she was a line in a treaty. To her father, she was a problem to be managed and in time married off. To the nation, she was a symbol, the bright young hope, the clean future after a generation of royal scandal and debt.

Everyone wanted what she stood for. Very few seemed to want her.

In February of 1811, the old king's mind failed for the last time, and George, Prince of Wales, was sworn in as Prince Regent, ruler of Britain in all but name, and master now of every hour of his daughter's life. Charlotte was not invited to watch.

Instead, on the morning of the ceremony, she had a horse brought out and rode it slowly back and forth across the gardens outside Carlton House, trying to catch a glimpse through the ground-floor windows of the moment that handed her father his power. The heir to the throne on the outside of the glass looking in.

By the time she was 17, Charlotte had become the most valuable unmarried woman in Europe. Her father intended to spend her. The plan was neat and cold and entirely about power. She would marry William, the hereditary Prince of Orange, heir to the throne of the Netherlands.

In December of 1813, worn down and pressured, Charlotte agreed. She met the young man. She did not much like him. Then she read the small print. The marriage would require her, at least for part of each year, to leave England.

She would not leave her country. She was the heir to Britain. Britain was where she belonged, and she was not going to be shipped abroad and quietly forgotten.

She fought the clause through months of negotiation, and when she understood that no clause could truly protect her, she made a decision that no British princess had made before her. She broke it off herself.

She wrote to the Prince of Orange and told him plainly, if they married, her mother must be welcome in their home. It was a condition she knew he could not accept. When the prince refused, Charlotte had her way out. The engagement was over.

Her father's response tells you everything about him. He did not argue. He did not reason. He simply moved to shut her away. He would dismiss her entire household and send her to Cranbourne Lodge deep in Windsor Great Park, where she would be allowed to see no living soul but the Queen.

It was a cage. And when the order was read to her, Charlotte did something that stunned everyone who heard of it. She ran.

On a July evening in 1814, the heir to the throne of Great Britain walked out of her own front door into a public London street alone. She did not even know how to summon a cab. A man watching from a window came down and helped her flag a common hackney carriage.

She climbed in and gave the driver the address of her mother's house across town. And so the future Queen of England fled through the streets of her own capital in a hired cab, running away from home.

Through the night they argued and slowly it became clear to Charlotte that the law itself was against her. A long-standing ruling gave the monarch, and so the regent, near total authority over his family. She could run into a hundred streets. There was nowhere the law would let her stay.

In the small hours, the Whigs advised her to go back to her father's house and the next day she did. She had lost. But the country had watched her lose, and the country did not forget.

One future Lord Chancellor summed up the public mood in four words, "All are against the prince." To a nation already tired of the regent's debts and mistresses and extravagance, here was the whole quarrel in a single image. The vain controlling father and the spirited daughter fleeing into the street rather than be sold.

They loved her for it. When she was sent that summer to the seaside at Weymouth, crowds gathered along the roads simply to see her coach pass. At the resort itself, the townspeople lit up a building after dark with a line of lamps that spelled out across the night, "Hail Princess Charlotte, Europe's hope and Britain's glory."

There was a private cost to that summer. Before she left for the coast, her father came to tell her that her mother was leaving England, going abroad to the continent for an extended stay. It was the last time Charlotte would ever see her.

The girl who had said no had learned something in her defeat. She had discovered that she could not escape her father by running. There was only one door out of his house that the law would honor. It was marriage.

If she could not run from her cage, she would have to choose the one person permitted to open it. And this time she was determined she would choose him herself.

She had met him almost by accident in the summer of 1814 at a party at a London hotel. Among the officers in the room was a quiet, tall, strikingly handsome young cavalry general in Russian service. A prince from a duchy so small and so poor that no one considered him a serious match for anyone, least of all the heir to the British throne.

His name was Leopold of Saxe-Coburg. He was correct where others were grasping. When Charlotte invited him to call on her, he stayed less than an hour and then did something that impressed even her suspicious father.

He wrote to the Prince Regent afterward apologizing for any impropriety, making no claim, asking for nothing. He had no fortune and no power to offer. What he had was tact and patience and a stillness that must have felt to a girl raised among people who wanted things from her almost unbelievable.

Her father would not hear of it. Leopold was poor and minor and useless to the grand chessboard of European marriages. The Prince Regent stalled, refused, changed the subject, sent his daughter away to think again.

Charlotte, who had learned in the street the summer before that she could not win by running, set about winning the only way left to her. She wore him down. She argued in person and on paper month after month. She refused every alternative.

In January of 1816, from Windsor, she finally put it to her father in writing in words that left no room at all. "I no longer hesitate," she wrote, "in declaring my partiality in favor of the Prince of Coburg, assuring you that no one will be more steady or consistent in this their present and last engagement than myself."

This time, worn down himself, her father gave way. When she was allowed at last to sit with Leopold and her father together over dinner, she wrote afterward with a joy that is almost startling to read coming from her pen.

I find him charming, she wrote, and go to bed happier than I have ever done yet in my life. And then a line that carries underneath it the whole weight of the childhood we have watched. A princess never, I believe, set out in life with such prospects of happiness. Real domestic ones, like other people.

They were married on the 2nd of May, 1816, at 9:00 in the evening in the crimson drawing room at Carlton House. Outside, the streets of London were so thick with well-wishers that the wedding party could barely get through them.

Inside the impoverished bridegroom stood in the uniform of a British general and spoke his vows. When he reached the part where he promised to endow his bride with all his worldly goods, the bride was heard to giggle. It was a small, human, irreverent sound. It was entirely Charlotte.

Her father grudgingly bought them a house. It was called Claremont, a handsome estate in Surrey set in quiet parkland an easy distance from London. Parliament granted the once penniless Leopold an income of £50,000 a year, and for the first time in her life, Charlotte had walls of her own to stand inside.

She filled it deliberately with everything her childhood had lacked. She planted a garden and fussed over the flowers and made excited plans for a little tea house among them. She walked the grounds with Leopold and their dogs.

When she learned that the years after the war had thrown many of the local men out of work, she and her husband hired them. The able-bodied to improve the estate, and the old men of the village, the ones no one else would take, to potter along the walks, pulling weeds and spreading gravel, so that they might have wages and dignity both.

For 18 months, the loneliest young woman in Britain was simply, quietly at home.

In the spring of 1817, Leopold sent word to the Prince Regent. His daughter was expecting a child and there was every hope of her carrying it safely to term. The heir was going to have an heir.

The pregnancy of Princess Charlotte became a national obsession. Bookmakers opened wages on whether the child would be a boy or a girl. Newspapers reported her every reported symptom.

In the city, economists sat down and did the arithmetic of a royal birth and calculated in cold figures what it would be worth. The arrival of a princess, they reckoned, would lift the stock market by 2 and 1/2%. The arrival of a prince by 6%.

Charlotte was a robust young woman with a hearty appetite. Her medical men decided this was a danger. Fashionable obstetric theory of the day held that a mother should be lowered before her confinement, kept quiet, kept thin, her strength deliberately reduced so that the birth might be easier.

From the late summer of 1817, her doctors put her on a strict meager diet. They bled her repeatedly, drawing off blood as a matter of routine, in the sincere belief that they were helping her. Stockmar, watching, grew uneasy.

No one meant her harm. That is the quiet horror of it. The best physicians in the kingdom, attending the most important patient in the kingdom, weakened her by inches in the months before she would need every ounce of her strength, and called it care.

The expected date came and went in October. The great officers of state gathered at Claremont to wait, and when nothing happened, dispersed again. The queen went off to Bath. The Prince Regent went off to the country to shoot.

They left behind the doctors and a nurse, and Charlotte, growing heavier and more tired, and Leopold, who never left her side. On the 3rd of November, in a quiet house in Surrey, the waiting ended, and Princess Charlotte went into labor.

The labor was long and slow and terribly hard. Through the first day, the doctors watched and waited and did nothing. The chief physician, Sir Richard Croft, held to the cautious school of his profession. Let nature take its course. Do not intervene.

Monday became Tuesday. Tuesday wore toward Wednesday. And Charlotte, who had been weakened for months by diet and bleeding, labored on hour after hour after hour, with a patience her attendants never forgot.

At 9:00 on the evening of the 5th of November, it was over. Charlotte was delivered of a large baby boy. He was, by every account, a beautiful child, perfectly formed, the image of the royal family. And he was dead.

He had never drawn breath. They worked over the little body, rubbing it, trying every art they knew to wake it, and none of it was any use.

Charlotte took the news with a composure that breaks the heart to read of. She had endured more than two days of agony to bring him into the world, and when they told her the child was gone, she said only that it was the will of God.

She asked for a little nourishment after her long fast. She spoke calmly. She seemed, to the exhausted men around her, to be out of danger at last.

Late that night, a bulletin was issued from Claremont and carried to London. Her Royal Highness, it said, was doing extremely well. Across England, people who had gone to bed grieving the lost child, comforted themselves that at least the mother had survived.

Leopold, warned to nothing, took an opiate to help him rest, and finally lay down. The great officers of state departed for London, satisfied the danger had passed. The house grew quiet.

A little after midnight, Charlotte began to vomit. She grew restless and cold, and complained of a sharp pain in her stomach. The nurse, alarmed, sent for the doctors.

Croft came, and found his patient chilled to the touch, struggling to breathe, and bleeding, bleeding that would not stop. He applied hot compresses, tried to warm her, tried to hold the life in her by force. The blood came anyway.

He sent for Stockmar, and begged him to bring Leopold. Stockmar went first to the dying woman. Charlotte reached out and caught his hand. Her mind was going. The room was slipping. "They have made me tipsy." She told him.

He left her side to go and rouse Leopold, who was drugged and hard to wake. As he went, he heard her voice call after him through the dark twice, using the pet name she had for him. "Stocky." "Stocky."

He turned back. When he reached her, she was dead. She was 21 years old.

The night filled with the sound of galloping horses as it had on the night of her birth. But now they carried the other kind of news out from Claremont to London, and from London across the whole of the kingdom. The Princess Charlotte is dead.

It broke over the country like a wave. Bells that had been made ready to ring in celebration told instead for mourning.

Her grandmother, the old queen, sat down to write to the Prince Regent and could barely hold the pen. "How painful it is for me to take up my pen at this moment." She wrote. "When I had flattered myself to make use of it by giving you joy." "Which it has pleased the Almighty to turn to grief, a mourning for us all."

Her mother, far away on the continent, was not even told by her own family. She learned that her only child was dead from a passing stranger and fainted where she stood.

Her father, the most powerful man in the kingdom, was so shattered that his doctors feared for him. He could not attend her funeral.

Leopold, woken from his drugged sleep to be told that his wife and his son were both gone in a single night, walked into a silence that would never really lift.

At Claremont, Leopold gave an order. Nothing in her room was to be moved. The cloak and bonnet she had thrown down after her last walk were to stay where they had fallen. Her boots, her watch left on the chimney piece, exactly where her own hand had placed it.

All of it was to remain untouched, as though she might come back through the door at any moment and take up her life where she had set it down. He kept it that way for years.

The grief did not stay at Claremont. It went everywhere. The shops emptied of black cloth. The exchange and the courts and the docks fell silent. Even the gambling dens shut their doors on the day of her funeral.

One man who knew the country well said it plainly that it was as though every household in Britain had lost a favorite child. The nation's own poet, Lord Byron, who had once thought of courting her himself, wrote her into his verse and asked the question the whole kingdom was asking. Fond hope of many nations, art thou dead?

And then there was the strangest turn of all. Charlotte had been the only legitimate grandchild of the old king. When she died and her son with her, the direct line of succession simply ended. There was no heir.

The aging, comfortable royal dukes, her father's middle-aged brothers, most of them settled with mistresses and debts, were sent scrambling to marry in haste and produce a legitimate child before it was too late.

One of them, the Duke of Kent, married a German princess, Leopold's own sister. Two years after Charlotte was laid in her tomb, they had a daughter. They named her Victoria.

Had Charlotte lived, there would have been no Queen Victoria, the reign that gave its name to an age, the empire, the 63 years on the throne. All of it flowed through the space that one young woman's death left behind.

The Queen Britain got was born out of the Queen Britain lost.

Her doctors never recovered, either. Three months after that night, still blamed by a grieving public for the forceps he did not use, Sir Richard Croft was attending another difficult birth in another house when he took up a pistol and shot himself.

As for Leopold, he went on to become a king in his own right, the first king of the Belgians, and an uncle and adviser to that niece named Victoria. He married again out of duty and had a family, but his own doctor, the man who had heard Charlotte's last words, wrote the truest epitaph either of them ever received.

"November," Stockmar wrote, "saw the ruin of this happy home and the destruction at one blow of every hope and happiness of Prince Leopold. He has never recovered it."

Decades later, an old king admitted to that same niece on the throne that he had never in all his life found again the feeling of happiness that had blessed his short years with the wife he chose.

The cloak stayed on the chair. The watch stayed on the chimney piece, and in a village in Surrey, in a house she had made her own, the small daily objects of a life waited a long time for a hand that never came back to move them.